Where to stay in Costa Rica: the regions compared for groups

How to choose where to stay in Costa Rica

Costa Rica is small on a map and slow on the road. Mountain highways, two-lane bridges and afternoon rain mean that 100 miles can take three hours. So the most useful question isn't "where is nicest?" but "how many bases can this trip support?"

• Five days or fewer: one base, close to your arrival airport.
• Six to nine days: two bases, ideally flying into one airport and out of the other.
• Ten days or more: two or three bases, with at least three nights in each.

For groups there's a second filter: bed count. Most of Costa Rica's vacation rentals and boutique hotels are built for couples and families of six. Finding one property for 20 or 30 people narrows the map quickly, which is why the honest answer below names regions where big groups have real options, and regions where you'll probably end up splitting across several rentals.

Hotel, villas or one whole estate?

A large resort hotel can take 25 people, but they'll be spread down corridors and there's nowhere for the whole group to sit down together except a restaurant. Several neighboring villas keep costs down but split the group every evening. A single whole-property rental keeps everyone under one roof (or one gate), with a kitchen, a pool and a dining table big enough for all of you. It usually works out cheaper per person too. Bella Vista's team compares the options in detail in hotel vs private resort, and our large vacation rentals page lines up all three estates side by side.

The regions at a glance

Airport times are approximate and for a private van. Drive times between our estates come from our hosts' own transfers; see the getting-around guide.

Guanacaste: Tamarindo, Playa Avellanas and the north Pacific

If your group pictures Costa Rica as a beach trip, this is where to stay. Guanacaste is the driest region, with reliable sun from December to April, and its airport at Liberia receives direct flights from many US cities. That makes it the easiest region to reach for a short trip.

Tamarindo is the busy hub: restaurants, nightlife, surf shops and boat trips. A few beaches south, Playa Avellanas is quieter, with a long surf beach and very little development. Groups who want the town without staying in it often base themselves nearby and drive in for an evening. Johnny's Beach Bungalow sits a three-minute walk from the sand at Avellanas, with Hacienda Pinilla's golf and pickleball about ten minutes away.

Suits: beach-first families, surf groups, weddings, bachelor and bachelorette trips. Skip it if your group's priority is rainforest and wildlife: the coast is dry forest, not jungle.

Arenal and La Fortuna: the adventure base

La Fortuna, at the foot of Arenal Volcano, packs more activities into a small area than anywhere else in the country: zip lines, hanging bridges, white-water rafting, canyoning, the La Fortuna waterfall and a long list of hot springs. For a group with mixed interests it's the easiest place to keep everyone busy, because people can split up for the morning and meet again for dinner.

It rains in every month here, the volcano spends a lot of its time in cloud, and it's about three hours from either international airport. The Majestic Lodge is in El Castillo, on the quieter side of the volcano near Lake Arenal, with ten en-suite bedrooms under one roof. The lodge's own site has the local detail: things to do in La Fortuna and the hot springs worth your time.

Suits: adventure groups, retreats, multi-family trips. Skip it if nobody in the group wants to do anything except swim and read.

The central mountains and Central Valley

Most visitors pass straight through the middle of the country on the way from San José to somewhere else. For groups, that's often a mistake. The mountains west of the Central Valley are mild all year, an easy drive from the main airport, and within reach of beaches, rivers and waterfalls on the Pacific slope.

Bella Vista is a gated mountaintop with four private homes, 80 minutes from San José airport and about 35 minutes from the Pacific. It works especially well as the first stop: nobody has to sit in a van for four hours after a red-eye. One guest described it as perfectly in the middle of Poás Volcano, Arenal and Manuel Antonio, which is how we'd describe it too.

Suits: pickleball groups (four private lit courts), weddings, reunions with grandparents and toddlers. Skip it if you want to walk out of the door onto the sand.

Manuel Antonio, Monteverde, Nosara and the Caribbean

We don't have estates in these regions, and some of them are wonderful. Here's how we'd think about each for a group.

Manuel Antonio

A national park with monkeys, sloths and beaches inside it, next to a hillside town of hotels and restaurants. It's the classic wildlife-plus-beach stop. The park is busy and large group lodging is limited, so many groups visit it as a long day trip rather than staying there. From Bella Vista it's about two hours.

Monteverde

High, cool cloud forest with hanging bridges and night walks. The access roads are winding and the lodging is mostly small, which makes it better as a day trip or a single night than as a base for 25 people. It's within reach of Arenal.

Nosara and Santa Teresa

The yoga-and-surf towns of the Nicoya Peninsula have a strong following and beautiful beaches. They're also remote, with long stretches of rough road. Great for a small group with time; harder for a large group on a schedule.

The Caribbean coast

Puerto Viejo and Cahuita feel like a different country: reggae, Caribbean cooking, and a rainfall pattern that's often drier in September and October than the Pacific. The drawback is distance. It doesn't combine easily with the Pacific side in a single week.

How to combine regions in one trip

The routes that work best for groups follow the geography rather than fighting it. Fly into San José, work your way north and west, and fly home from Liberia. That open-jaw ticket removes a four-to-five-hour backtrack at the end of the trip.

• 7 days: three nights at Arenal, then the beach. Fly SJO in, LIR out.
• 10 days: three nights each in the mountains, at the volcano and on the beach.
• 14 days: the same three stops with four or five nights each, plus day trips to Manuel Antonio or Monteverde.

The full day-by-day versions are on the Costa Rica itinerary page, and the trip builder prices any combination per person. Because one team runs all three resorts, one conversation covers the dates, the quote and the vans between stops.

Mountains · Bella VistaWhere 28 guests sleep at Bella VistaFour homes on one gated mountaintop: main house, guest house, treehouse and tiny house.

Open →

Volcano · Majestic LodgeThe Majestic Lodge's ten en-suite roomsEvery bedroom with its own bathroom, facing Arenal Volcano and the lake.

Open →

Ocean · Johnny'sA large-group beach house at AvellanasSix suites and a tiki hut around the pool, three minutes from the sand.

Open →